What I Appreciated
- Architecture and ambience: The hotel is beautiful, with stunning views that create an impressive first impression.
- Cleanliness and comfort: The hotel was generally clean, and I particularly appreciated the plush towels, comfortable bedding and quality house robes.
- Goodnight ritual: This was a lovely and unexpected touch. It added a sense of thoughtfulness to the stay and was one of the more memorable aspects of the experience.
- In-room refreshments: The drinks in the refrigerator, generous supply of bottled water and tea provisions were appreciated.
Areas of Concern
A. Reservation Management and Communication
The delay in responding to my emails and WhatsApp messages during the reservation process was disappointing and quite frankly, unacceptable for a hotel of this calibre.
Securing a reservation should be a seamless experience, not an exercise in repeatedly seeking attention. Had I not already been determined to experience the property, I would have taken my business elsewhere.
The first impression of a hotel begins long before a guest walks through its doors. Unfortunately, this was not a promising start.
B. Check-in Experience and Guest Relations
My check-in experience with Nafissatou was underwhelming. There was no welcoming smile or warmth, and the approach to resolving my payment issue was not as proactive as I would have expected.
A guest arriving at a luxury hotel should feel welcomed, valued and reassured. Problem-solving should be proactive, not reactive, particularly when a guest is already experiencing an inconvenience.
C. Room Allocation – Connecting Rooms
We travelled as a group of three and specifically requested connecting rooms. We were informed that this arrangement was available, yet we were not accommodated accordingly.
There was also an unexplained discrepancy surrounding the connecting-room arrangement, which I would be happy to elaborate on separately.
When a hotel confirms a particular arrangement, guests should be able to rely on that commitment. If circumstances change, clear communication and an appropriate explanation should follow.
D. Inconsistency in Room Amenities
I observed some rather surprising inconsistencies between our rooms.
My friend's room had hand cream at one sink, while ours did not. Her hand wash was also empty, which raises questions about the thoroughness of the housekeeping replenishment process.
I would have assumed that these amenities were checked and replenished daily.
Furthermore, the absence of basic shower accessories such as a loofah or sponge from housekeeping was surprising. While guests may bring their own, providing such basic conveniences would be a thoughtful addition, particularly for guests who may have forgotten theirs.
Luxury is often defined by anticipating needs rather than waiting for guests to ask.
E. In-room Facilities and Guest Information
The wardrobe handles had tassels that appeared to serve a particular purpose, but there was no explanation of their functionality.
I actually requested an iron, only to discover that one was already available in the room.
A simple explanatory note or a brief mention during check-in would have prevented this unnecessary request.
F. Air Conditioning and Maintenance Response
I sweat considerably and noticed that the air-conditioning temperature in our room was noticeably higher than in my friend's room.
I contacted maintenance to have this checked, but nobody showed up.
This is particularly disappointing. Once a guest reports a problem affecting their comfort, the expectation is that the issue will be acknowledged, attended to and resolved.
G. Breakfast Experience – Below Brand Expectations
The breakfast selection did not do justice to the hotel's brand positioning.
I expected a more impressive and varied selection, particularly from a property presenting itself as a luxury hospitality destination.
Additionally, the lady attending to the egg station could have been considerably more welcoming and cheerful. Her demeanour did little to enhance the breakfast experience.
There should also be more options for omelette fillings and customisation.
Breakfast is an important part of the hotel experience, and it should feel like a highlight rather than an area where standards fall short.
H. An Uncomfortable Experience Over Tea Bags
I was particularly embarrassed when my friend and I took two additional tea bags each from the breakfast area.
This was an uncomfortable and rather awkward experience, and I cannot recall encountering anything similar at any hotel I have stayed in.
I understand that hotels have policies around food and beverage consumption, but there are better ways to manage such situations without making paying guests feel uncomfortable over something as basic as tea bags.
I. Goodnight Ritual – A Lovely Concept, Poorly Executed in Our Case
I genuinely commend the goodnight ritual. It was a lovely surprise and a thoughtful gesture.
However, there appears to be a gap in how the service is executed.
For example, a room occupied by two guests should receive two complete goodnight set-ups. In our case, we received one set-up instead of two.
J. Spa Reservation Management
The spa reservation experience was another disappointment.
A time slot had been confirmed for my friends and me, only for us to subsequently receive a call informing us that the previously agreed time was no longer available.
This reflects poor coordination and reservation management.
Guests should not be given confirmed appointments only to have those arrangements withdrawn later. The spa should have a reliable booking system that prevents double-booking and unnecessary inconvenience.
Additionally, one of the house coats provided had a hole in it. This is a basic quality-control issue that should have been identified before the item was issued to a guest.
K. Housekeeping Failure – Missed Room Cleaning
Perhaps one of the most disappointing incidents was that my friend's room was not cleaned on the third day.
She had specifically asked the housekeeping team to return after she left the room, yet this was not done.
There is little justification for a guest's room being left unserviced after a specific request has been communicated.
This raises concerns about communication between housekeeping personnel, task tracking and supervisory checks.
For a hotel of this standard, this is a fundamental service failure.
Overall Assessment and Conclusion
A beautiful hotel does not automatically translate into a luxury hospitality experience.
Luxury is in the details: timely communication, warm welcomes, attention to individual needs, consistency, effective problem-solving and the ability to deliver on commitments.
Unfortunately, my experience was characterised by too many avoidable inconveniences and inconsistencies. From the reservation process and check-in experience to maintenance, breakfast, spa coordination and housekeeping, there were several instances where basic service expectations were not met.
What is particularly concerning is that these were not isolated issues involving one department. The observations cut across multiple touchpoints, suggesting a broader need to review service coordination, staff training, supervision and quality assurance.
I travelled with friends expecting a memorable luxury experience. While the physical property certainly delivered on aesthetics, the overall service experience fell short of expectations.
Would I recommend the hotel? I would recommend the property for its beauty, ambience and stunning views.
Would I return? Not without some confidence that these service gaps are being addressed.
My advice to management is simple: Do not allow the beauty of the property to overshadow the importance of the guest experience, as what ultimately determines whether they return is how they are treated.